Muted Rosy lip colors on different skin tone / natural lip colors / warm & cool tones

Creator says the velvet lipstick has a slightly tacky but smooth application and spreads well. It is a lively muted rose on her and a natural, subtly lively rose on another model; she calls it an easy base color for cool tones.

Creator says the color applies lightly yet spreads smoothly and reads as a muted rose on her lips. Across the other lips it can read rose or deeper ash rose; she calls it a good color for all tones because the mute quality is not too strong.

Creator says 12 is more coral than rose and warmer than 04, but still good as a base or MLBB color. It reads orange-ish on the comparison lips and she considers it suitable for warm tones.

Creator says the stick applies softly with velvet/silky feel. 04 reads as warm rose-coral on all three lips and is a good base color, including for cool tones when applied lightly.

Creator says 07 is darker than Morning Brew and reads as a more lively, darker pink on the comparison lips. She calls it a good MLBB/base color and explicitly recommends 07 over 06 for someone wanting a livelier result.

Creator says the matte lipstick spreads smoothly with a soft finish. It reads as warm muted rose on her, natural enough to look like Karina's own lip color, and a muted rose with slight white tinge on Roseline; she says it suits cool-toned users well.

Creator finds the side-by-side colors make a natural muted-rose gradient on her lips. On the two other lips it reads as lively or naturally pretty rose; she calls it comfortable for daily use and a good MLBB/base rose color.

Creator says the matte lipstick is not stiff and spreads smoothly. Though redder and deeper than the name suggested on her lips, it is less vivid in person than on camera and she considers it a good base color.

Creator says the initially stiff formula becomes softer and somewhat moist with application. It is lively pink and works as a base when applied thinly on her and Karina; it also goes well with Roseline.

Creator finds the grayish rose slightly murky on her lips and deep for a base, but calls it a good MLBB/base color. On two other lips it appears brighter or like a natural lip balm; she calls it a good moisturizing lipstick with smooth moist spread.